Diplomatic or Lying Immunity: International Law is Evolving.

Colosseum-Rome-Italy-1896International Law is nothing but law of Jungle. Opportunism makes and breaks the law. The term diplomat is normally used in society to call a person as ‘shrewd but sweet liar.’ We all know what is the present meaning of the term ‘Weapon of Mass Destruction’ or ‘WMD’. It has nothing to do with Weapons anymore, rather it means a cultivated lie. Problem is that the world has changed a lot since Vienna Convention in 1961. The term rogue state was hardly used back then. Deflation and recessions were obsolete. And PIIGS was not yet invented. It means debt ridden Portugal, Ireland, Italy, Greece and Spain.
The Government of India is licking the egg on its face for taking a soft if not stupid stand in supporting the bail of Italian Marines (Riflemen Massimiliano Latorre and Salvatore Girone) accused of killing fishermen in Indian waters. After Italy conveyed that marines shall not return to India to face trial, Supreme Court has restrained Italian Ambassador Daniele Mancini from leaving the Country. The cries on the trumpet of International Law, notwithstanding. The Ambassador had filed a personal undertaking by way of an Affidavit before court that the accused persons would be returned to court custody after 4 weeks. It is well accepted norm that diplomat can tacitly conspire against the host nations. They can use diplomatic immunity to smuggle prohibited things. They can ridicule the Governments, Nations, cultures, traditions and people with impunity. Now we want to know if they are immune from ridiculing the system of Justice as well.
It is in the news today that European Union has threatened Indian Government of serious consequences. I wonder what they meant. Will they withdraw the posters, advertisements and commercials inviting Indians to travel Europe and spend their money? Will they withdraw advertisements and billboards inviting Indian students to study abroad? That will save lot of foreign currency. Will they throw out Tatas, Mittals and other businessmen who are running the Industries, Europeans could not profitably run. Would they send all the Indians working there, back home? That shall be a boon for India with an educated work force. They will return with their wealth in Euros.
It is a time. It is the 22nd century. It is an opportunity to change hypocrisy, deceit, lying and diplomacy. The least Italy could do was to share proper information about 102 Indians whom it is holding as prisoners in a barbaric and secret way. Instead it is arm twisting an open and fair trial given to Italian citizens, in India.
It appears Italy forgot two factors. One: Office of Supreme Court of India is the strongest institution in India. It has in past, delivered bold decisions, which were legislative in nature and which no Supreme Court of any country could dare especially against the Government and the Court has popular support.
Two: Next year is election year. All political parties are in election gear. If they chose to make this issue an election plank, Italy would wish that she knew what a hornets’ nest looks like, in India.

Humans learn and acquire skills, but they have inherent learning difficulty from experiencing. Let us wait and see as to how this ‘Lying Immunity’ develops after its tryst with Supreme Court of India.

English: Maps shows a group of countries known...

English: Maps shows a group of countries known as the PIGS (Portugal, Italy, Greece, Spain), shown in #FF0000. Since 2009, Ireland (#CC6666) and the United Kingdom (#CC9999) have been suggested as members, creating PIIGS or PIIGGS, the additional “G” standing for Great Britain. (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

The relevant article 31 of Vienna Convention of 1961 is relevant in this regard. It is extracted below and it appears that ambassador has himself left the door open to reach him. Italy should read clause 1(c) & 4, a few more times.

“1. A diplomatic agent shall enjoy immunity from the criminal jurisdiction of the receiving State. He shall also enjoy immunity from its civil and administrative jurisdiction, except in the case of:
(a) A real action relating to private immovable property situated in the territory of the receiving State, unless he holds it on behalf of the sending State for the purposes of the mission;
(b) An action relating to succession in which the diplomatic agent is involved as executor, administrator, heir or legatee as a private person and not on behalf of the sending State;
(c) An action relating to any professional or commercial activity exercised by the diplomatic agent in the receiving State outside his official functions.
A diplomatic agent is not obliged to give evidence as a witness.
3. No measures of execution may be taken in respect of a diplomatic agent except in the cases coming under subparagraphs (a), (b) and (c) of paragraph 1 of this article, and provided that the measures concerned can be taken without infringing the inviolability of his person or of his residence.
4. The immunity of a diplomatic agent from the jurisdiction of the receiving State does not exempt him from the jurisdiction of the sending State.”

Added on 22nd March, 2013
As expected the Italy has blinked in eye ball match and it appears that the rifleman is reaching India to face the trial.

© Sandeep Bhalla

4 thoughts on “Diplomatic or Lying Immunity: International Law is Evolving.

  1. Pingback: Diplomatic Immunity to Documents! | Sandeep Bhalla's Blog

  2. To an unknown friend from Genova/Chiavari, Liguria, Italy who Identified as Tom but gave fake email address (IP address There is no reason to express the hostility, as you did. We are only discussing issues in public not to pass judgement on anything. There is no reason to believe that views expressed here are universally acceptable.
    Due to your fake identity, your comment has been moved to trash. It would have been better if you had left proper identity. However you are requested to search PIIGS on google or wikipedia and you will find that Italy had its soverign debt at 118% of GDP in 2010. Such huge debt is the problem for Italy. Debts do affect the leverage of the country.


  3. That is originally hilarious. “vote us off the island.” I would wish that we may all wake up. It was a judgement on capital punishment where it was mentioned “eye for eye would render whole world blind.” Power corrupts. Everywhere and at every level. Economic success makes a person delirious, how nations can be different. Do you think any country is or would be different, in similar circumstances? I doubt it. What I know is that with 17% population and about 7% of land/resources, the people of this country are going to have a tough sojourn here!!!! while it lasts.


  4. Language is just incredibly fascinating. And, yes, we have words like “WMD” that get bandied about but meaning accrues pretty readily and they come to stand for something other than what was originally intended. We are just so incredibly dishonest with ourselves and with each other, and I mean this individually and collectively. And I’m often appalled at my own country with its heavy-handed arrogance. I often wonder why you guys put up with us, why you don’t just “vote us off the island”!!! But please don’t until I’ve completed my brief sojourn here!!!!


Please share your views.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.